The Best Down Comforters: The Ultimate Guide 2017

Last updated: March 16, 2017
Best Goose Down Comforters
We tested all the popular brands in our search to find the best down comforter. The costs ranged from reasonable to very expensive and we found quality comforters at multiple price points.

Buying The Right Comforter For Your Needs

If you are looking for a comforter that you can use year-round:

The best all-season goose down comforter is Lands’ End Essential Down Comforter.

Do you have icy cold feet at night? Want to save money by keeping your thermostat lower? Or maybe you live in the northern United States or up in Canada where winters are freezing cold and long:

Then you will need to get an extra warm winter weight comforter which is the warmest grade of comforter available. The best winter warmth comforter is Pacific Coast Ultimate Extra Warmth Comforter.

If you have allergies, then a comforter that is truly hypoallergenic (allergen-free) is vital unless you want to wake up with itchy eyes and a runny nose.

The best hypoallergenic (real) down comforter does not exist. Choose one of the top rated comforters on this list and cover it up with an allergen blocking protector like the Pacific Coast AllerRest Cover. For the extra cautious, who want to stick with synthetic fillings, the best down alternative comforter is the Pinzon Hypoallergenic Down Alternative Comforter.

And finally, there are those of us who are extra picky about our bedding. If you hate heavy blankets, then a light weight goose down throw is the perfect choice during the hotter summer months.

The best lightweight down blanket/throw is Highland Feather’s La Palma Down Insert.

For those of you who have a large budget and want to splurge on the softest, loftiest, fluffiest, warmest comforter:

The best luxury down comforter that money can buy is Cuddledown 1000 Fill Power Batiste Down Comforter.

What did we look for in our testing and reviews?

  • Close and tight stitching: Proper stitching keeps feathers inside the comforter. Stitching keeps the down feathers in place inside your comforter and keeps the down from traveling to one corner and bunching into clumps on one side while leaving you with another side that is thin and filling-less. Good stiching also means less feathers escaping onto your bedroom floor, gathering into dust bunnies under your bed.
  • Baffle boxes: Baffles are strips of fabric that separate the interior of your comforter into boxes. The fabric forms walls that keep feathers inside each box and allow the comforter to expand to its fluffy heights. Cheaper comforters do not have baffle boxes, just stitching between the two sides of the comforter. This compresses the down inside and results in a heavy, not-fluffy comforter.
  • High thread count fabric: Thread count is the number of threads in an inch of fabric. The higher the number, the tighter the fabric. You want a high thread count surface for your comforter because it is better at keeping down feathers from leaking out. The fabric will also feel smoother and softer. Not that this point matters because you’re going to use a duvet cover (right!?).
  • High fill power: This is the equivalent of ‘thread count’ for measuring down feathers. A high fill power down is fluffier and warmer than lower fill power feathers. So, go for comforters with a fill power of at least 600 for the most bang for your buck.
  • Pure down feathers: Many ‘down’ comforters are actually a mix of (more expensive) goose down and (cheaper) duck feathers or even chicken feathers. Not only are these feathers not very good at keeping you warm, but they will also make your comforter feel flat and heavy instead of soft and fluffy. Another downside to cheaper feather fillings is that these feathers are stiff and sharp. Everybody’s felt a painful poke from the feathers in cheaper comforters. This is the reason why. Look for comforters with at least 70% pure down.
  • Ethically harvested down: Some budget manufacturers source their goose or duck down from China where the feathers are plucked from live animals. We preferred comforter makers who use Canadian or European goose down where the feathers are responsibly harvested from abandonned nests once the geese or ducks are finished rearing their young.
  • Realistic down alternative fillings: For hypoallergenic comforters with down alternative fillings, we looked for a convincing plushness and lightness that was comparable to down. We avoided comforters that had heavy polyester fillings that would eventually turn lumpy. We also avoided comforters with synthetic fillings that felt plasticky or smelled like chemical fumes.
  • Manufacturer warranty/guarantee: A good down comforter should last for years (or decades with care). Be wary of comforter companies that only offer a one year warranty. The one year mark is usually when you begin to notice problems like feathers leaking out and feathers shifting to one the side of the comforter near your feet. Look for comforter brands with at least a 5 year warranty or product guarantee.
  • Correct size: For some reason or another, down comforters are often the wrong size. So a comforter that’s supposed to fit a queen or king bed ends up being an inch short or it comes right to the edge of the mattress. Needless to say, this looks funny and ruins your perfectly made bed. We looked for comforters that were true to size or even generously sized with a couple inches spilling over the edge of the mattress.

The Best All-Season Comforter For Year-Round Use

Lands’ End Essential Down Comforter

The Lands’ End Essential Down Comforter is an exceptional quality down comforter for under $200 even for a King size comforter. Warm enough for most climates, but not too thick that you can’t use it all year.

Lands' End Year Round Essential Down Comforter

Pros

  • 550 fill-power down is warm enough for most winter climates, but not too warm for spring or autumn use.
  • Has loops at each corner so you can tie the comforter to your duvet cover to prevent shifting and bunching.
  • 300 thread-count cotton sateen cover is tightly woven to prevent leaking feathers.
  • Baffle box construction keeps feathers in place and prevents empty spots inside the comforter without squishing the feathers.

Cons

  • Imported comforter, not made in the US. This shouldn’t matter too much since Lands’ End sources their products through an ethical supply chain which guarantees that their products do not contain live plucked down.
  • Might not be warm enough for extremely cold winter temperatures or if you keep your thermostat in the 50s.

Lands’ End Essential Down Comforter

Lands' End Year Round Essential Down Comforter
Rating: 4 out of 5

A great budget conscious choice with features that are usually found in $300+ comforters such as:

  • Real baffle box construction to hold feathers in place yet allow maximum fluffiness.
  • 550 fill-power down that’s light yet extra warm.
  • 300 thread-count sateen cotton cover fabric to prevent leaking feathers.
  • Fabric loops at the corners so you can tie your comforter to your duvet cover.
  • Any time return or exchange. There’s no time limit to getting your refund or exchange if you’re not satisfied with the comforter. You can do an exchange/refund in person or by mail for a small fee.

Check Prices


The Best Extra Warm Comforter For Freezing Cold Feet In The Winter

Pacific Coast Ultimate Extra Warmth Comforter

The Pacific Coast Ultimate Extra Warmth Comforter is an extra warmth down comforter with 600 fill-power goose down that will keep you toasty warm even if you keep your room cool in the 50s or if you sleep cold. Oversized so you have plenty of comforter to wrap around yourself or to snuggle into without letting in any drafts.

Pacific Coast Ultimate Extra Warmth Down Comforter

Pros

  • Filled with 600 fill-power goose down for the ultimate warmth without adding any extra weight or bulk.
  • 500 thread-count cotton fabric cover is silky smooth and keeps even the tiniest of down feathers from escaping.
  • Real baffle boxes keep feathers in place and prevent empty cold spots inside your comforter.
  • Duvet loops at the corners of the comforter mean you can tie the comforter to duvet cover so it won’t bunch or shift out of place.
  • Oversized so it drapes invitingly over the edge of your bed.
  • Comes with a 10 year manufacturer warranty.

Cons

  • This is an oversized comforter so it might not work with your normal duvet cover. The dimensions of this comforter are:
  • Twin: 68” x 88”
  • Full/Queen: 90” x 98”
    *King: 108” x 98”

Pacific Coast Ultimate Extra Warmth Comforter

Pacific Coast Ultimate Extra Warmth Down Comforter
Rating: 4 out of 5

An extra thick, soft, and lofty down comforter for those freezing cold winter nights or ice cold feet. Oversized so you have plenty of drape over the edge of your bed or to wrap around your feet. Be sure to let the comforter air and fluff up when you unpack it as it will be compressed flat out of the box.

Check Prices


The Best Hypoallergenic And Down Alternative Comforters

Do Hypoallergenic Down Comforters Really Exist?

If down alternative fillings just don’t hit the spot for you, then the only choice is to get an allergen blocking duvet cover for your down comforter.

Do not believe manufacturer claims about ‘hypoallergenic down’. Even if a company claims to wash their down ten times and with special soaps, there’s no guarantee that it is free of goose dander (if you’re really allergic to goose feathers).

Or maybe you’re allergic to something else in down bedding like mold or dust mites.

An allergen blocking comforter protector will block all of these allergy causing substances from getting into your comforter (or leaking out from your comforter).

This is the only dependable way of sleeping with down bedding if it triggers allergic symptoms like itchy eyes, swelling, or runny noses.

Pacific Coast AllerRest Duvet Cover

The AllerRest Cover is made from 100% cotton and is machine washable. The specially woven fabric is lab tested to block dust mites, feathers, and other allergy causing substances without the use of chemicals or plastics.

Pacific Coast AllerRest Comforter Cover

Pros

  • You can use the cover with your favorite down comforter. There’s no need to sacrifice warmth and softness for allergy protection.
  • The cover is easy to wash at home and keeps your comforter clean.
  • Made from 100% cotton so it won’t feel crinkly or smell like plastics like other allergen blocking bedding protectors.

Cons

  • The cover only comes in white and the barrier weave of the fabric doesn’t feel very smooth to the touch. You’ll probably want to get a nicer looking duvet cover to go over the allergen blocking cover.

Pacific Coast AllerRest Duvet Cover

Pacific Coast AllerRest Comforter Cover
Rating: 5 out of 5

An inexpensive way for allergy sufferers to enjoy the softness and warmth of real down without itchy eyes or runny noses. Easy to wash and care for and since the cover is made from cotton, you won’t even know it’s there under.

Check Prices

Pinzon Hypoallergenic Down Alternative Comforter

If your allergies are so severe that you can’t take the risk of real down, then the Pinzon Hypoallergenic Down Alternative Comforter is the most down-like synthetic allergen-free comforter.

Pinzon Hypoallergenic Down Alternative Comforter

Pros

  • The filling is allergen-free, but has the same plushness and lightness as real down feathers.
  • There’s 50+ ounces of fill inside the comforter to keep you warm even through the coldest autumn and winter months. The down alternative fill is equivalent to 550 fill-power down.
  • The comforter is box stitched so you don’t have to worry about the filling bunching up and turning lumpy over time.
  • Has loops at the corners so you can tie it to your duvet cover and prevent shifting.
  • Oversized to give a nice amount of drape over the edge of your bed.

Cons

  • Like almost all down alternative bedding, some people claim they notice a plasticky smell from the filling. You should give the comforter a couple days to air out after you unpack it.
  • Hot sleepers might find this comforter too warm. If you tend to run hot, go with the medium warmth over the extra warmth version.
    *

Pinzon Hypoallergenic Down Alternative Comforter

Pinzon Hypoallergenic Down Alternative Comforter
Rating: 4 out of 5

A down alternative comforter that gives the natural plush feeling of down with none of the allergy causing downsides. This is a comforter that is on the warm/hot side so go with the lighter warmth version if you tend to get sweaty at night.

Check Prices


The Best Light Down Blanket For Warmer Spring Weather And Hot Summer Nights

Highland Feather La Palma Lightweight Down Duvet Insert

While most people sleep under down for the warmth, others prefer the softness and lightness of down even during the hotter months. If you want to keep on using down bedding during the spring and summer months, then a thinner and lighter down blanket like Highland Feather’s La Palma Down Insert is what you want.

Highland Feather Lightweight Summer/Spring Down Blanket

Pros

  • Products are made in Canada and they follow the ethical and quality standards of the Down Association of Canada.
  • Filled with 550-575 fill-power European down for warmth without the weight.
  • Baffle box construction lets the down expand and fluff up to its maximum height.
  • Comes with a 15 year manufacturer warranty.
  • Highly rated by buyers from FL, AL, SC, TX aka places where it gets really really hot. This should be the perfect lightweight comforter for summer use anywhere.

Cons

  • No ties at the corners to attach the comforter to your duvet cover.
  • The cotton cover is 260 thread count which is lower than the 300 thread count we prefer. This should not be a problem as long as you use a duvet cover over the comforter.

Highland Feather La Palma Lightweight Down Duvet Insert

Highland Feather Lightweight Summer/Spring Down Blanket
Rating: 4 out of 5

A lightweight but warm down comforter for hot spring and summer nights. Baffle boxes and 550 fill power European down keeps you warm without extra weight pressing down on you.

Check Prices


The Best Luxury Goose Down Comforter

Cuddledown 1000 Fill Power Batiste Down Comforter

Cuddledown 1000 Fill Power Batiste Down Comforter
The ultimate luxury comforter. 1000 fill power European down is the highest quality down that money can buy and it will keep you warm through Arctic cold winters. The outer fabric is made from 100% German batiste cotton fabric, the lightest and finest European crafted cotton available. Constructed with baffle boxes, this is the lighest and fluffiest comforter that money can buy.

Cuddledown 1000 fill power european downcomforter with batiste cotton

Pros

  • Quality is apparent in every part if this comforter from the 1000 fill power down feathers, to the German batiste cotton fabric, to the tight and neat stitching.
  • This comforter is extra warm and fluffs up to an incredible height due to the baffle box construction.
  • Made in the US from European materials.

Cons

  • Expensive and out of most people’s budgets. This comforter is a dream to sleep in and the price reflects this. If there was a perfect and flawless down comforter, then this is it.

Cuddledown 1000 Fill Power Batiste Down Comforter

Cuddledown 1000 fill power european downcomforter with batiste cotton
Rating: 5 out of 5

The perfect comforter by every measurement. Only the highest quality European materials are used in this American crafted comforter. If you have an unlimited budget, then this is the comforter to get. Buy it for life and sleep like royalty.

Check Prices


Compare the highest rated comforters

The perfect down comforter will depend on your sleeping needs. We’ve found that these are the best comforters in each category:

Like what you’ve read?

If so, please join us to get email updates. You’ll get access to exclusive tips & tricks and members only giveaway alerts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *